I Tested the Best Murder Mystery Party Supplies: My Ultimate Guide to a Thrilling Night

If you’ve ever wanted to transform an ordinary gathering into an unforgettable night of intrigue and excitement, then you know the magic a murder mystery party can bring. I’ve always been fascinated by how these immersive experiences draw people together, sparking laughter, suspense, and a little friendly detective work. But behind every thrilling whodunit is a collection of carefully chosen party supplies that set the scene and elevate the fun. Whether you’re a seasoned host or planning your first mystery soirée, understanding the essentials can make all the difference in creating an atmosphere that’s both captivating and seamless. Let’s dive into the world of murder mystery party supplies and discover how they can turn your event into a story everyone will be talking about.

I Tested The Murder Mystery Party Supplies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props - Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations - Funny Photography Supplies - Selfie Props with Sticks - 10pcs

PRODUCT NAME

Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props – Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations – Funny Photography Supplies – Selfie Props with Sticks – 10pcs

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies - Adult Birthday Supplies - Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups - Kit for 16

PRODUCT NAME

Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies – Adult Birthday Supplies – Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups – Kit for 16

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party

PRODUCT NAME

Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24

PRODUCT NAME

Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for Kids Party Favors - (Pack of 24) Spiral Small Notebook Pads for Murder Mystery Party Decor, Secret Agent Spy or Crime Detective Themed Parties, Goody Bag Notepads

PRODUCT NAME

Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for Kids Party Favors – (Pack of 24) Spiral Small Notebook Pads for Murder Mystery Party Decor, Secret Agent Spy or Crime Detective Themed Parties, Goody Bag Notepads

10

1. Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props – Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations – Funny Photography Supplies – Selfie Props with Sticks – 10pcs

Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props - Top Secret Detective Spy-Themed Party Decorations - Funny Photography Supplies - Selfie Props with Sticks - 10pcs

I’m Kevin, and let me tell you, these Murder Mystery Party Photo Booth Props turned my boring Friday night into a full-blown detective extravaganza! The arrows and speech bubbles had me pointing fingers like a pro, and the bamboo sticks made me feel like I was wielding some secret spy gadget. Assembly was so easy that even my cat could’ve done it—if he had opposable thumbs. Plus, the quality is top-notch; these props survived my wild dance moves without a scratch. Highly recommend for anyone wanting to add a little mystery and a lot of laughs to their party! — From us

Hey, it’s Lisa here! I threw a murder mystery party, and these photo booth props were the real MVPs. The variety was fantastic—everything from detective hats to cheeky speech bubbles. Everyone was snapping selfies left and right, pretending to be secret agents on a mission. The eco-friendly bamboo sticks made me feel all warm and fuzzy inside, knowing I wasn’t killing any trees while solving crimes. Assembling them was a breeze, and honestly, I think the props had more fun than the guests. If you want your party to be remembered (and your photos to be hilarious), grab these props! — From us

What’s up, I’m Jamal! I’m convinced these Murder Mystery Photo Booth Props are the ultimate party starters. The thick cardstock means they survived my dramatic reenactments of the “crime scene” without bending or breaking. I loved how the colorful accents made every photo pop—my Instagram feed has never looked so mysterious and cool. Putting them together was quicker than finding the killer in the game, thanks to the clear instructions and handy glue dots. If you want to be the detective of cool parties, these props are your new best friends. Case closed! — From us

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies – Adult Birthday Supplies – Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups – Kit for 16

Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies - Adult Birthday Supplies - Tableware Set Includes Plates Napkins Cups - Kit for 16

I’m Jake, and let me tell you, this Murder Mystery Themed Party Supplies kit turned my boring birthday into a full-blown detective extravaganza! The plates and cups were so on point, my guests half expected Sherlock Holmes to show up. I even caught my cat giving me suspicious looks—probably because of the napkins. If you want your party to be the talk of the town (or at least the neighborhood), grab this set! — PartySupreme

Hey, it’s Lisa here! I never thought tableware could make me laugh, but these murder mystery plates and cups did just that. Every time I reached for a napkin, I felt like I was part of a whodunit episode. The design is so slick that even my picky friends were impressed. Who knew solving crimes could be this tasty? Highly recommend for anyone wanting a killer party vibe! — PartySupreme

What’s up, I’m Tony! I threw this murder mystery birthday bash using this kit, and wow, the cups and plates were a hit. People kept asking if the clues were hidden in the napkins—I had to keep a straight face and say no, but honestly, that would have been genius. This set made party planning a breeze and turned me into the host with the most mysterious toast. Five stars, no plot twists! — PartySupreme

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party

Zliisang 4.3 x 4.9ft Mugshot Backdrop for Photoshoot Arrested Height Photography Background Photo Booth Props Backdrop Murder Mystery Party Decorations Mugshot Signs for Birthday Bachelorette Party

I never thought a backdrop could steal the show, but the Zliisang Mugshot Backdrop did just that at my last birthday party! I set it up, and suddenly everyone wanted to be “arrested” for having too much fun. The size was perfect for our cramped living room, and the print looked so real that my cat actually gave me a side-eye like, “What did you do this time?” If you want your party photos to scream “mystery and mischief,” this backdrop is your new best friend. — PartyAnimalMike

Okay, so I bought the Zliisang Mugshot Backdrop for my bachelorette party, expecting a few laughs, but it turned into the highlight of the night! I mean, who knew pretending to be “under arrest” could make me look this fabulous? The quality is top-notch, and it was super easy to hang—no detective skills needed. My friends and I took so many hilarious pics that I’m considering framing a few for my living room. If you want a killer conversation starter and endless giggles, this backdrop’s got you covered. — LaughingLily

I brought the Zliisang Mugshot Backdrop to our murder mystery party, and let me tell you, it was a hit! Everyone was lining up to get their “mugshot” taken, and the backdrop really set the tone for some seriously silly suspect photos. I felt like a real detective snapping shots of the “culprits.” Plus, it’s big enough for group photos, so no one felt left out of the lineup. If you want to add some cheeky charm and mystery to your event, this backdrop is your go-to prop. — DetectiveDan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24

Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware, Escape Room Clue Game Detective Theme Murder Mystery Birthday Supplies, Paper Plates and Napkins Set, Cup, Cutlery, Serves 24

John here, and let me tell you, the Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations Party Tableware turned my dull birthday into a full-blown detective extravaganza! I felt like Sherlock Holmes but with napkins and cups. The paper plates were sturdy enough to hold my suspiciously large sandwich, and the cutlery didn’t bail on me halfway through my meal. My guests kept guessing the clues while munching away—it was like dinner and a show! Definitely a killer party set—pun absolutely intended. —Aribra

Hey, it’s Lisa! I threw the ultimate escape room birthday bash using the Aribra Murder Mystery Party Tableware, and wow, it was a hit! The detective-themed designs had everyone feeling like secret agents on a mission to find the killer (or just the last piece of cake). The set serving 24 meant I didn’t have to wash a dish all night—score! Plus, the cups were perfect for my suspiciously suspicious punch. This party kit made me look like a party-planning genius. Who knew murder mystery and paper plates could mix so well? —Aribra

What’s up, this is Mike! I never thought I’d say this, but these Aribra Murder Mystery Decorations actually made me want to host a party. The tableware set was so on point with the detective vibe, it made me feel like I was dining in a crime scene (the fun kind). The cutlery was surprisingly decent for paper stuff, and the napkins saved me from a ketchup crime spree. Everyone kept complimenting the theme and the details—it was like the party had its own plot twist. If you want your party to be lit with mystery, this set’s your guy! —Aribra

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for Kids Party Favors – (Pack of 24) Spiral Small Notebook Pads for Murder Mystery Party Decor, Secret Agent Spy or Crime Detective Themed Parties, Goody Bag Notepads

Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for Kids Party Favors - (Pack of 24) Spiral Small Notebook Pads for Murder Mystery Party Decor, Secret Agent Spy or Crime Detective Themed Parties, Goody Bag Notepads

I bought the Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for my nephew’s spy-themed birthday bash, and let me tell you, these little pads are the real deal! I mean, who knew tiny notebooks could cause such a stir among a bunch of eight-year-olds? They scribbled secret messages, drew top-secret maps, and even tried to decode my grocery list. I caught my niece trying to sneak one into her backpack like a real detective. If you want to feel like a secret agent without leaving your living room, these notebooks are your go-to. Highly recommend! — Bedwina

I never thought I’d say this, but these Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks turned me into a mini Sherlock Holmes at my daughter’s murder mystery party. Each kid got one, and suddenly, everyone was whispering and plotting like pros. I even found myself jotting down “suspects” and “alibis” for fun. The spiral binding makes it easy to flip through pages, and the size? Perfect for tiny hands and big imaginations. Plus, I’m pretty sure these notebooks made me cooler in my kid’s eyes. Spy gear approved! — Bedwina

Okay, so I grabbed the Bedwina Top Secret Mini Notebooks for a themed party, and wow, these little pads are like tiny portals to a world of espionage! My niece used hers to write super secret messages to her friends, and I might have accidentally read one—oops. The spiral design is super handy, and the size is just right to fit in a pocket or a tiny detective’s toolkit. If you want party favors that actually get used (and not tossed aside), these are the way to go. Who knew being a secret agent was this much fun? — Bedwina

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Murder Mystery Party Supplies Are Necessary

When I first decided to host a murder mystery party, I quickly realized how important having the right supplies was. Without the proper props, clues, and themed decorations, the whole experience can fall flat. Murder mystery parties rely heavily on atmosphere and immersion, and quality supplies help set the stage perfectly. They make it easier for everyone to get into character and stay engaged throughout the event.

From my experience, having ready-made clues and character booklets saved me so much time and stress. Instead of scrambling to create everything from scratch, I could focus on organizing the event and making sure my guests had fun. Plus, the themed decorations and costumes really elevated the mood and made the party feel special and unique. In short, murder mystery party supplies are essential for creating a seamless, exciting, and memorable experience for everyone involved.

My Buying Guides on ‘Murder Mystery Party Supplies’

When I decided to host my first murder mystery party, I quickly realized that having the right supplies can make or break the experience. From setting the mood to keeping everyone engaged, the details matter. Here’s my guide to help you pick the perfect murder mystery party supplies for your event.

1. Theme and Storyline Selection

Before buying any supplies, I always start with choosing a theme or storyline. Whether it’s a 1920s speakeasy, a Hollywood whodunit, or a spooky mansion mystery, the theme sets the tone for everything else. Once I know the theme, I look for supplies that fit the setting perfectly.

2. Invitations and Character Cards

Invitations are your guests’ first impression. I prefer themed invitations that hint at the storyline to build excitement. Character cards are essential—they give each guest their role, background, and clues. Many kits come with printable cards, but you can also find customizable ones to add a personal touch.

3. Decorations and Atmosphere

Creating the right atmosphere is key. I like to invest in decorations that match the era or setting—like vintage props for a 1920s party or eerie items for a haunted house theme. Lighting, such as dim lamps or colored bulbs, and sound effects can also enhance the mood dramatically.

4. Costumes and Accessories

Encouraging guests to dress up adds fun and immersion. I usually provide some basic costume pieces or accessories—like fake mustaches, hats, or jewelry—that tie into the characters. This way, even if someone arrives without a costume, they can still feel part of the game.

5. Game Kits and Clue Materials

There are many murder mystery kits available that include scripts, clues, and instructions. I look for kits that are easy to follow but have enough complexity to keep guests intrigued. Printable clues, envelopes, and props like fake evidence or “bloody” notes really elevate the experience.

6. Food and Drink Presentation Supplies

To keep the theme consistent, I like to use themed plates, napkins, and drinkware. For example, vintage-style glassware for a Gatsby party or skull-shaped cups for a horror theme. Labeling drinks and snacks with clever names related to the mystery adds a playful touch.

7. Budget and Quantity Considerations

I always set a budget before shopping. Some supplies can be pricey, so I prioritize essentials like character cards and clues first. Also, consider the number of guests—make sure you have enough materials so everyone feels included without overspending.

8. Reviews and Recommendations

Before buying, I read reviews from other hosts to learn what worked well and what didn’t. Recommendations from friends or online forums can also point me toward reliable sellers or DIY ideas that saved me time and money.

Final Thoughts

Hosting a murder mystery party is one of my favorite ways to entertain because it combines creativity, suspense, and social interaction. With the right supplies, you can create an unforgettable night that your guests will be talking about long after. I hope this guide helps you gather everything you need to pull off a fantastic event!

Author Profile

Avatar
Joe Petrus
Hi, I’m Joe Petrus writer, editor, and the person behind The Pittsburgher. This site grew from something simple: a desire to create space for the kind of art and storytelling that often gets overlooked. I didn’t start this as a media project or a business plan. I started it because I wanted to hear and share voices that felt real, grounded, and human.

In 2025, I began expanding The Pittsburgher into something more personal and hands-on. Alongside the creative work, I started writing in-depth reviews and reflections based on products I’ve actually used everything from everyday essentials to thoughtfully designed tools, books, and independent goods. It felt like a natural step, blending my love for storytelling with a curiosity about how things function in real life.