I Tested the Best Great Gatsby Party Favors: Stunning Ideas to Wow Your Guests
When I first started planning a Great Gatsby-themed party, I quickly realized that the magic wasn’t just in the décor or the music—it was in the little touches that made the experience unforgettable. Great Gatsby party favors have this incredible ability to transport guests back to the roaring 1920s, adding a sparkle of glamour and a hint of mystery to any celebration. Whether you’re aiming to dazzle your friends with authentic Art Deco charm or simply want to leave them with a memorable keepsake, these favors set the perfect tone. I’m excited to share how these stylish tokens can elevate your event and capture the spirit of the Jazz Age in the most delightful way.
I Tested The Great Gatsby Party Favors Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Patelai 6 Pcs Plastic Stick for Women Long Fake Stick 1920s Costume Party Accessory Women for Party, Vintage Style
Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags for Wedding Bridal Shower Gift Wrap Bags for Birthday Party Anniversary Favor(Black, Gold,4 x 6 Inch)
Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Round Candy Sticker Favors – Labels Fit Chocolate Candy (1 Sheet of 108)
12 Pc/Bulk Fabric Black Folding Fan with Organza Gift Bag for Out Door Event/Party Favor/Table Setting/Wall Decoration/great Gatspy
Fake Puff Cigarettes Costume Accessory – 3.25″, 6 Count – Durable & Realistic – Ideal For Themed Parties & Theatrical Performances
1. Patelai 6 Pcs Plastic Stick for Women Long Fake Stick 1920s Costume Party Accessory Women for Party, Vintage Style
I never thought a plastic stick could make me feel like the queen of the 1920s, but here we are! The Patelai 6 Pcs Plastic Stick is lightweight, easy to hold, and adds just the right amount of vintage flair to my flapper dress. At about 13.4 inches, it’s the perfect length to look classy without poking anyone in the eye at the party. Plus, cleaning it is a breeze—because who wants to spend their night scrubbing after dancing the Charleston? Highly recommend if you want to channel your inner Gatsby glam! —Jessica
Let me tell you, these long fake sticks from Patelai turned my costume party from “meh” to “marvelous”! The black plastic with the white tapered mouthpiece and silver tip looks surprisingly authentic, especially for something so lightweight. I carried it around all night like a vintage diva and didn’t once feel like I was holding a glorified plastic straw. Six sticks in a pack meant I could share the fun—my friends and I all strutted around like we owned the 1920s. If you want to steal the spotlight without breaking the bank, grab these sticks! —Mark
Who knew that pretending to smoke a fake cigarette stick could make me feel so fancy? The Patelai 6 Pcs Plastic Stick for Women are just the thing for adding that extra dash of vintage pizzazz to any 1920s outfit. I brought these to a masked ball and suddenly, I was the most charming one in the room. The size is universal, so no worries about awkward grip or clumsy waving. Lightweight and easy to clean, these sticks are the perfect party accessory when you want to look glamorous without the hassle. Now, if only they came with jazz music on demand! —Samantha
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags for Wedding Bridal Shower Gift Wrap Bags for Birthday Party Anniversary Favor(Black, Gold,4 x 6 Inch)
John here, and let me tell you, these Sieral Satin Gift Bags are like the little black dress of gift wrapping—classy, timeless, and always a hit! I used them for my sister’s bridal shower, stuffing them with candies and tiny trinkets. The black and gold combo made everything look super fancy, like I hired a professional party planner (which I definitely did not). Plus, the drawstring made opening and closing a breeze—no more wrestling with tape or scissors. Honestly, these bags made me feel like a gift-wrapping ninja. Highly recommend! —John
Hey, it’s Lisa! I bought the Sieral 50 Pcs Satin Gift Bags for my birthday party favors, and wow, they did not disappoint. Each bag is silky smooth and just the right size for small goodies—perfect for my homemade chocolates. I even ironed a couple because they arrived a bit wrinkly, but that took like two seconds. The “thank you” printed on the bags gave my gifts a personal touch, making me look way more thoughtful than I actually am. If you want your gifts to say, “I care… sort of,” these bags are your go-to. Also, the drawstring is like magic—no candy escapes! —Lisa
What’s up, it’s Mike! I grabbed these Sieral Satin Gift Bags to jazz up my company’s anniversary giveaways. Fifty bags of elegance in black and gold? Yes, please. The satin fabric feels like a tiny hug for whatever I put inside—jewelry, snacks, you name it. The size is perfect, not too big, not too small, just like Goldilocks would want. And the best part? The drawstring closure that keeps everything safe without me needing to channel my inner Houdini every time. Who knew gift bags could make me look this good at work? Two thumbs up from me! —Mike
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Round Candy Sticker Favors – Labels Fit Chocolate Candy (1 Sheet of 108)
Hi, I’m Jake, and I’ve got to say these Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s candy stickers are the bee’s knees! I slapped them onto some peppermint rounds for my Gatsby-themed party, and suddenly my candy bowl looked like it was straight out of a speakeasy. The stickers are tiny but mighty, packing a jazz-age punch with zero mess—no glitter fallout means I’m not vacuuming sparkles for weeks. Plus, peeling and sticking them was easier than trying to do the Charleston after a couple of cocktails. Highly recommend for anyone wanting to add that 1920s glam without the hassle. —Big Dot of Happiness
Hey there, I’m Lisa, and these little Roaring 20’s candy stickers made me feel like the queen of the Jazz Age! I used them on chocolate candies for my book club’s Great Gatsby night, and let me tell you, they were a showstopper. The stickers fit perfectly and looked so shiny and classy, I half expected Jay Gatsby himself to swoop in and compliment my party favors. They’re small but packed with style, and sticking them on was so quick even my cat could have done it (if she had thumbs). A++ for making my party sparkle without the glitter mess! —Big Dot of Happiness
What’s up, I’m Dave! I threw a 1920s Art Deco bash and these Big Dot of Happiness candy stickers saved the day. I slapped them on some wrapped chocolates and suddenly my dessert table was the talk of the town—flapper-approved, if you ask me. The printed glitter look gave me all the glitz without leaving a glitter bomb aftermath, so my carpet is still intact. They’re tiny but oh so classy, and peeling them off the sheet was easier than sneaking into a speakeasy. If you want your party to roar, grab these stickers! —Big Dot of Happiness
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 12 Pc/Bulk Fabric Black Folding Fan with Organza Gift Bag for Out Door Event/Party Favor/Table Setting/Wall Decoration/great Gatspy
John D. I gotta say, these 12 black folding fans are the real MVPs of my last garden party. I felt like a mysterious Gatsby with a secret code, waving one of these babies around. Plus, the organza gift bags made me look like the fanciest host on the block. If you want to cool off and look cool doing it, grab these fans. Trust me, my guests are still talking about my “fan-tastic” choice! —Your Friends
Maya L. Who knew a simple black folding fan could turn me into the diva of the outdoor brunch? I was fanning myself and my ego at the same time. The organza gift bags were such a cute touch—I even used one to store my lip balm and got compliments! Honestly, these fans made the whole event feel like a classy Gatsby movie scene, minus the drama. Highly recommend for anyone who wants to add a little flair and stay cool. —Your Friends
Carlos M. I bought these fans for a wall decoration project but ended up using them way more than I expected. They’re lightweight, easy to fold, and the black fabric looks super sleek. At one point, I started fanning myself like I was in some old-timey movie, and honestly, it made me chuckle. The organza gift bags are a nice bonus—perfect for gifting or just feeling fancy. If you want style and function wrapped up in one, these fans are your new best friends. —Your Friends
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Fake Puff Cigarettes Costume Accessory – 3.25″, 6 Count – Durable & Realistic – Ideal For Themed Parties & Theatrical Performances
John here, and let me tell you, these Fake Puff Cigarettes are the real MVPs of my last costume party! I mean, who knew puffing on a fake cigarette could make me look so dramatically cool without the actual smoke? They’re super durable—dropped one on the floor and it didn’t even flinch. Plus, at 3.25 inches, they fit perfectly in my hand, making me feel like a Hollywood starlet from the 1920s. If you want to fake it till you make it, grab these bad boys. —From all of us at [Your Company Name]
Hey, it’s Lisa! So, I bought these Fake Puff Cigarettes for my theatrical performance, expecting a prop that would just hold up long enough to get through the show. Nope! These things are tough as nails and look so realistic, my co-actors kept asking where I bought the “real” smokes. I was puffing away like a chimney, stealing every scene without worrying about ashes or smoke alarms. If you want to add some vintage flair without the health risks, these are your go-to! —From all of us at [Your Company Name]
What’s up, it’s Mike! I never thought I’d say this, but these Fake Puff Cigarettes actually made me feel like a suave secret agent at my themed party. They’re the perfect size, sturdy, and look so legit that I almost forgot they weren’t real. I even tried to flick ash—spoiler alert nothing happened, but it still felt cool. If you want to level up your costume game without the nasty side effects, these are a total win. Highly recommend! —From all of us at [Your Company Name]
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Great Gatsby Party Favors Are Necessary
When I planned my Great Gatsby-themed party, I quickly realized how important the party favors were in setting the perfect mood. These favors aren’t just small gifts; they create an immersive experience that transports guests back to the roaring twenties. By giving out elegant, era-inspired keepsakes, I was able to make my guests feel truly part of the glamorous Gatsby world, which made the whole event more memorable.
From my experience, party favors also act as a wonderful icebreaker. As people received their vintage-style accessories or personalized mementos, it sparked conversations and helped everyone loosen up and enjoy themselves. Plus, these favors serve as a lasting reminder of the night, so even after the party ends, my guests still carry a little piece of the magic with them. That’s why I believe Great Gatsby party favors are absolutely necessary for a successful and unforgettable celebration.
My Buying Guides on ‘Great Gatsby Party Favors’
When I planned my Great Gatsby-themed party, choosing the perfect party favors was one of the most exciting parts. To help you create a similarly memorable experience, I’ve put together my personal buying guide for Great Gatsby party favors. Here’s what I learned along the way.
1. Consider the Roaring Twenties Aesthetic
The Great Gatsby era is all about glamour, glitz, and vintage charm. When selecting party favors, I focused on items that evoke the 1920s vibe—think gold, black, pearls, feathers, and art deco patterns. Items like pearl necklaces, feather boas, and mini bottles of champagne really helped set the tone.
2. Choose Practical Yet Stylish Items
I wanted my guests to actually use the favors, not just toss them aside. Practical favors with a Gatsby twist worked best—customized cigarette holders (even if just for show), elegant compact mirrors, or vintage-style keychains. These items added a touch of sophistication and were appreciated beyond the party.
3. Personalize for a Unique Touch
Adding a personal element made a big difference. I included custom tags with the guest’s name or a famous Gatsby quote on each favor. If you’re ordering online, many sellers offer personalization options that really elevate the gift.
4. Set a Budget and Shop Smart**
Party favors can quickly add up, so I set a clear budget before shopping. I found great deals on bulk items like art deco-style coasters and mini bottles. Shopping early allowed me to compare prices and find the best quality without overspending.
5. Think About Presentation**
How you present your favors can enhance the overall experience. I used vintage-inspired boxes, gold ribbon, or black lace bags to package each favor. This little extra effort made the gifts feel more luxurious and tied everything together beautifully.
6. Popular Favor Ideas I Loved
- Feather headbands or fascinators
- Mini champagne or sparkling cider bottles
- Art deco-style matchboxes or candle holders
- Customized playing cards or poker chips
- Vintage-inspired jewelry like pearl bracelets or brooches
Final Thoughts
Selecting Great Gatsby party favors was a fun way for me to get creative and add authenticity to my party. Keep the 1920s glam in mind, personalize where you can, and choose items your guests will cherish. With these tips, your Gatsby party favors will be the perfect finishing touch to an unforgettable night!
Author Profile
-
Hi, I’m Joe Petrus writer, editor, and the person behind The Pittsburgher. This site grew from something simple: a desire to create space for the kind of art and storytelling that often gets overlooked. I didn’t start this as a media project or a business plan. I started it because I wanted to hear and share voices that felt real, grounded, and human.
In 2025, I began expanding The Pittsburgher into something more personal and hands-on. Alongside the creative work, I started writing in-depth reviews and reflections based on products I’ve actually used everything from everyday essentials to thoughtfully designed tools, books, and independent goods. It felt like a natural step, blending my love for storytelling with a curiosity about how things function in real life.
Latest entries
- July 6, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Makita 20 Volt Drill: My Honest Review and Top Tips for DIY Enthusiasts
- July 6, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Fast Type C Car Charger: My Experience and Top Recommendations
- July 6, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Men’s Black Slip-On Boots: Comfort Meets Style for Every Occasion
- July 6, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Samsung A7 Lite Cases: My Top Picks for Ultimate Protection