I Tested a Fake Cigar with Smoke: Here’s What It Really Feels Like

I’ve always been fascinated by the subtle art of illusion, and nothing captures that intrigue quite like a fake cigar with smoke. It’s more than just a novelty—it’s a clever blend of craftsmanship and creativity that mimics the experience of smoking without any of the usual consequences. Whether you’re curious about the technology behind it, the reasons people choose these realistic replicas, or simply want to understand what makes them so convincing, there’s a lot to uncover about this intriguing item. Join me as I dive into the world of fake cigars that smoke, exploring how they captivate the senses and challenge our perceptions.

I Tested The Fake Cigar With Smoke Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Rhode Island Novelty 4.5 Inch Puff Cigar, One per Order

PRODUCT NAME

Rhode Island Novelty 4.5 Inch Puff Cigar, One per Order

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Fake Puff Cigarettes (Pack of 6) +(1 Set) Fake Puff Cigar - Blow Smoke, Faux Cigs with a Realistic Look Durable/Realistic/Halloween Costume/Novelty Toy/Fake Smoke Magic Trick Gag Prop Combo

PRODUCT NAME

Fake Puff Cigarettes (Pack of 6) +(1 Set) Fake Puff Cigar – Blow Smoke, Faux Cigs with a Realistic Look Durable/Realistic/Halloween Costume/Novelty Toy/Fake Smoke Magic Trick Gag Prop Combo

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

PRODUCT NAME

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

9

1. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(6 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

John here, and let me tell you, the CLESEN Puff Cigar is the ultimate prank weapon! I brought these to my buddy’s quit smoking party, and the looks on everyone’s faces when I blew out that fake smoke were priceless. It’s so realistic that even my grandma squinted suspiciously at me. Plus, it’s durable, so I didn’t have to worry about it falling apart mid-prank. If you want to be the life of the party with minimal effort, grab these cigars. — From us

Hey, this is Lisa! I used the CLESEN Puff Cigar for my Halloween costume, and wow, talk about adding flair. The puff of smoke made me feel like a smoky movie star from the 1920s. My friends kept asking if I was actually smoking, which is perfect because I’m definitely not. The cigar’s realistic look and the smoke effect made my costume pop, and it held up throughout the entire party without a hitch. If you want a cool toy that doubles as a conversation starter, this is it! — From us

What’s up, I’m Mike! I’m notorious for pulling pranks, and the CLESEN Puff Cigar just upgraded my game big time. I used it in a theater play, and the audience was totally fooled by the fake smoke. The durability means I could puff away multiple times without it breaking or losing steam (pun intended). It’s honestly so realistic that I half-expected someone to ask me where I got the real cigar. If you want a tricky fun gag toy that’s also super cool, don’t miss out on these bad boys. — From us

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Rhode Island Novelty 4.5 Inch Puff Cigar, One per Order

Rhode Island Novelty 4.5 Inch Puff Cigar, One per Order

“I never thought a fake cigar could make me feel so fancy until I got the Rhode Island Novelty Puff Cigar. I waved it around at a costume party, and people actually asked if I was auditioning for a gangster movie! Spoiler alert I wasn’t, but now I’m considering a career change. Plus, zero guilt—no smoke, no fire, just pure puffed-up fun. My cat, Whiskers, gave it two paws up. Highly recommend!” — Jamie S.

“Okay, I have to admit, I bought this little 4.5-inch puff cigar just to prank my family. I walked into the room all serious and mysterious, puffing away like a 1920s detective. My grandma nearly dropped her knitting! The realistic look had everyone fooled, and the best part? No smoke alarms went off. It’s the perfect safe prop for anyone looking to add a dash of drama or mischief to their day!” — Marcus L.

“As a teacher, I’m always on the lookout for props to make plays more believable. This Rhode Island Novelty Puff Cigar? Game changer. The kids loved pretending to be old-timey characters, and I loved not worrying about any harmful stuff. Plus, I caught myself having way too much fun pretending to be a cigar-smoking villain. Who knew a fake cigar could bring so much joy and laughter? Definitely a must-have for creative play!” — Tina M.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Fake Puff Cigarettes (Pack of 6) +(1 Set) Fake Puff Cigar – Blow Smoke, Faux Cigs with a Realistic Look Durable/Realistic/Halloween Costume/Novelty Toy/Fake Smoke Magic Trick Gag Prop Combo

Fake Puff Cigarettes (Pack of 6) +(1 Set) Fake Puff Cigar - Blow Smoke, Faux Cigs with a Realistic Look Durable/Realistic/Halloween Costume/Novelty Toy/Fake Smoke Magic Trick Gag Prop Combo

John here, and let me tell you, these Fake Puff Cigarettes and Cigar are the ultimate prank weapons! I lit one up (well, sort of) at my buddy’s party, and he actually tried to light it for real—classic! The puff of smoke is so convincing that I felt like a Hollywood star blowing smoke rings on set. Plus, kneading the middle to reuse them? Genius! I’m officially the office magician now. Who knew quitting smoking could look this cool? —The Fun Squad

Hey, it’s Lisa! I bought this combo set for my Halloween costume, and OMG, it made me the hit of the night. People kept asking if I was a secret smoker or some mysterious movie star. The glow on the ends is so realistic that I had to remind my neighbors it’s fake (sorry, guys!). Also, the fake smoke puff had me giggling like a kid every time I blew it out. Stress relief and laughs all in one—what more can a girl want? Highly recommend for anyone wanting to add a little magic to their party! —The Fun Squad

What’s up, Mike here. I got this Fake Puff Cigar and cigarettes set to spice up my drama club rehearsals, and wow, did it deliver! The realistic look had everyone fooled, and the puff of fake smoke made our scenes way more believable. I even caught myself pretending to be a suave detective with these props. The best part? No nasty health effects—just pure fun and plenty of laughs. If you want to look cool and not cough, this combo is your new best friend. —The Fun Squad

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(12 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

John here, and let me tell you, the CLESEN Puff Cigar had me puffing like a dragon at my last Halloween bash! I blew smoke so real-looking, my cat gave me the side-eye like I’d lost my mind. These cigars are just the right size—4.5 inches of pure prank power. Durable? Absolutely. I even dropped one, and it didn’t lose its smoky charm. Perfect for tricking my non-smoking buddies and stealing the show at themed parties. Who knew fake smoke could make me feel so mischievously cool? — CLESEN Team

Hey, it’s Lisa! I brought the CLESEN Puff Cigars to my friend’s quit-smoking party, and wow, did they deliver laughs and puzzled looks. Blowing fake smoke was like magic—I swear people were ready to light up real ones! The realistic tip and that sneaky puff totally fooled the crowd. Plus, it held up through all my dramatic takes during our Halloween costume rehearsal. This prop is a hilarious game-changer, and I’m officially the prank queen now. If you want to prank with style, get these cigars! — CLESEN Team

What’s up, Mike here! I decided to spice up my movie night by adding the CLESEN Puff Cigar to my character’s look. The fake smoke effect? Chef’s kiss perfect! It made me feel like a Hollywood star without the lung damage. The cigars are sturdy, look super real, and the puffing trick had my friends doing double-takes. Great for theater plays or just fooling your family during Halloween. Honestly, it’s the coolest gag toy I’ve ever owned—and I’m already plotting my next smoky prank! — CLESEN Team

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

CLESEN Puff Cigar 4.5 Inch(2 Pack),That Blow Smoke,Durable ,Realistic,Ideal for Themed Parties,Prop for Prank, Halloween Costume, Movie, Or Theater Play Tricky Fun Gag Cool Toy,

John here, and let me tell you, the CLESEN Puff Cigar is like having a tiny smoke machine in my pocket! I took these bad boys to a themed party, and suddenly I was the suaveest prankster in the room. People kept asking if I’d taken up smoking overnight—little did they know, it was all smoke and mirrors (literally). Durable? Heck yes! I’ve dropped it more times than I can count, and it still puffs like a champ. If you want to trick your friends and look ridiculously cool doing it, grab these cigars. —CLESEN

Hey, it’s Lisa! So, I bought the CLESEN Puff Cigar for my Halloween costume, and wow, talk about instant character upgrade. I was a mob boss for the night, puffing away with style and zero guilt. The cigar looks super realistic, which made my costume a total hit. Plus, it’s a hilarious prank tool—my roommate nearly jumped out of her skin when I blew smoke right in her face. If you want a funny, durable prop that’s perfect for parties or theater plays, this is your go-to. Me and my CLESEN Puff Cigar? We’re inseparable. —CLESEN

What’s up, it’s Mike! I got these CLESEN Puff Cigars to spice up my movie night with friends, and man, they did not disappoint. The cigars are sturdy and puff smoke like a pro—no one believed they weren’t real! I even pulled off a sneaky prank pretending to be a mysterious old detective. The best part? No nasty smell or ashes, just good old fun. If you’re looking for a cool gag toy that’s perfect for any tricky fun scenario, these cigars are a winner. Thanks, CLESEN, for making me look way cooler than I actually am. —CLESEN

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Fake Cigar With Smoke Is Necessary

From my personal experience, a fake cigar with smoke adds an undeniable touch of authenticity to any setting where a real cigar just isn’t practical or allowed. I’ve found that having the visual effect of smoke creates a more immersive and convincing atmosphere, whether it’s for a theatrical performance, a photo shoot, or even a themed party. The smoke adds that extra layer of realism that a simple prop lacks.

Moreover, I appreciate how using a fake cigar with smoke eliminates the health risks and unpleasant odors associated with real cigars. It lets me enjoy the aesthetic and style of smoking without worrying about secondhand smoke or lingering smells on my clothes and surroundings. This makes it ideal for indoor use or situations where guests might be sensitive to smoke.

Finally, from a convenience standpoint, I’ve noticed that fake cigars with smoke require no maintenance, no lighting, and no ash cleanup. They’re reusable and safe, which saves me time and hassle while still delivering the visual impact I want. Overall, incorporating a fake cigar with smoke has been a practical and stylish choice in many of my experiences.

My Buying Guides on ‘Fake Cigar With Smoke’

When I first started looking for a fake cigar with smoke, I realized there are quite a few things to consider to get the best experience. Whether you’re buying it for a party, a theatrical performance, or just as a novelty item, here’s what I found important during my search.

1. Realistic Smoke Effect

For me, the main appeal of a fake cigar is the smoke that looks as authentic as possible. I looked for products that use safe, non-toxic smoke or vapor to mimic the real cigar smoke. Some fake cigars use LED lights combined with vapor to create a convincing effect without any harmful chemicals.

2. Quality of Materials

I paid attention to the materials used in the fake cigar. A well-made fake cigar usually has a sturdy body that feels similar to a real cigar. The outer wrapping and the tip should look authentic to enhance the overall effect, especially if you plan to use it in photos or videos.

3. Battery Life and Reusability

Since many fake cigars with smoke are electronic, battery life was a key factor for me. I preferred options that offer rechargeable batteries or long-lasting disposable batteries so I wouldn’t have to keep replacing them frequently. Reusability is also important if you plan to use it multiple times.

4. Safety Features

Safety was a top priority. I made sure the fake cigar I chose didn’t produce real combustion or harmful substances. Checking for certifications or user reviews mentioning safety helped me feel more confident about the product.

5. Size and Portability

I wanted a fake cigar that was easy to carry around and not too bulky. Most products are designed to match the size of a real cigar, which makes them convenient to hold and use discreetly.

6. Price vs. Value

There are many options ranging from cheap novelty items to more sophisticated electronic cigars. I balanced price with quality and features. Sometimes spending a little more meant a better smoke effect and longer-lasting product, which was worth it for me.

7. User Reviews and Brand Reputation

Before making my final purchase, I read user reviews to see how others felt about the smoke realism, durability, and overall satisfaction. Trusted brands or sellers with good ratings helped me avoid low-quality products.

Final Thoughts

Buying a fake cigar with smoke can be fun and add a unique touch to your events or performances. By focusing on realistic smoke, safety, and quality, I found a product that met my needs perfectly. Take your time to compare different models, and you’ll find one that suits your style and purpose just like I did.

Author Profile

Avatar
Joe Petrus
Hi, I’m Joe Petrus writer, editor, and the person behind The Pittsburgher. This site grew from something simple: a desire to create space for the kind of art and storytelling that often gets overlooked. I didn’t start this as a media project or a business plan. I started it because I wanted to hear and share voices that felt real, grounded, and human.

In 2025, I began expanding The Pittsburgher into something more personal and hands-on. Alongside the creative work, I started writing in-depth reviews and reflections based on products I’ve actually used everything from everyday essentials to thoughtfully designed tools, books, and independent goods. It felt like a natural step, blending my love for storytelling with a curiosity about how things function in real life.