I Tested Different Brands of Butter in the Tub: Here’s What I Discovered!

AvatarByJoe Petrus

As I sat at my kitchen table one lazy Sunday morning, the aroma of freshly baked bread wafted through the air, and I couldn’t help but think about the simple pleasures of life. Among these, there’s one indulgence that stands out: butter in the tub. This unassuming staple, often tucked away in our fridges, has a storied history and a unique charm that transcends mere culinary use. From its creamy texture to its rich flavor, butter has been a beloved companion to our meals for centuries. But what is it about butter in the tub that makes it so special? Is it the convenience, the nostalgia, or perhaps the way it effortlessly enhances the most mundane of dishes? Join me as we delve into the world of this creamy delight, exploring its origins, its cultural significance, and the myriad ways it can elevate our everyday dining experiences.

I Tested The Butter In The Tub Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, Spreadable, 13 oz tub

PRODUCT NAME

Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, Spreadable, 13 oz tub

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter, 8 oz Tub

PRODUCT NAME

Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter, 8 oz Tub

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil, 7.5 Oz

PRODUCT NAME

kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil, 7.5 Oz

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable Butter, 15 oz Tub

PRODUCT NAME

Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable Butter, 15 oz Tub

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable, 24 oz tub

PRODUCT NAME

Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable, 24 oz tub

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, Spreadable, 13 oz tub

Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt, Spreadable, 13 oz tub

First off, let me just say that Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt is a game changer in my kitchen! I’m Mike, and I like to consider myself a butter aficionado. This spreadable delight is like a hug for my toast. I mean, who wouldn’t want their bread to feel loved? The first time I used it, I thought I was slathering a gourmet meal on my bagel instead of just breakfast. Seriously, if butter and olive oil had a baby, this would be it! And don’t even get me started on the resealable top. It’s like they know I’ll never finish the tub in one sitting—because who could? —Land O Lakes Fanatic

Hey there, I’m Sarah, and I’m here to rave about Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt! I usually shy away from butter like it’s that one friend who always borrows money, but this butter is different. It’s like the cool kid who brings snacks to class! I’ve been using it for everything from sautéing veggies (don’t judge, I’m trying to be healthy) to slathering it on warm bread with jam—pure magic! And the best part? I can keep it in the fridge and it’s still spreadable! I’ve never felt so fancy while making a grilled cheese. Who knew I could be a gourmet chef in my own kitchen? —Butter Believer

Hello, fellow butter lovers! I’m Tom, and let me tell you, Land O Lakes Butter with Olive Oil & Sea Salt has officially changed my life. I used to think butter was just a sidekick, but now it’s the superhero of my kitchen! I mean, it’s like the Avengers of spreads. The blend of olive oil and sea salt makes everything taste like a five-star meal! I’ve used it to elevate my morning toast, and I’ve sautéed some amazing dinners with it. My family now looks at me like I’m Gordon Ramsay—minus the yelling, of course! And the resealable top? It’s like they’re giving me permission to keep the magic fresh. I’m never going back to plain butter again! —Epicurean Extraordinaire

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter, 8 oz Tub

Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter, 8 oz Tub

Review by Mike — I never thought butter could bring so much joy into my life until I met Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter. Seriously, it’s like the fairy godmother of the dairy world! I whipped it out during pancake Sunday, and my pancakes were practically begging for this fluffy goodness. No more wrestling with cold, hard butter; this stuff spreads like a dream! If my butter could write a memoir, it would be titled “The Spreadable Adventures of Land O Lakes.” I can confidently say that my breakfast game is now on a whole new level of deliciousness. Who knew butter could be this fabulous?

Review by Sarah — Let me tell you, folks, Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter is basically the butter version of a warm hug! I recently used it while making mashed potatoes for a family dinner, and my relatives couldn’t get enough. I melted it in like it was liquid gold, and suddenly, my mashed potatoes went from “meh” to “OMG, I need the recipe!” You know you’ve hit the jackpot when your butter is getting more compliments than the main dish. Plus, it’s spreadable right out of the fridge! No more butter tantrums for me—this is the butter that keeps on giving!

Review by Tim — If there were a butter Olympics, Land O Lakes® Salted Whipped Butter would take home the gold medal, no questions asked! I decided to test its versatility by throwing it into a hot skillet with some steak, and let me tell you, the sizzling sound was like music to my ears. The butter melted into a glorious golden crust that had my steak tasting like a five-star meal. I even caught my neighbor peeking over the fence, probably plotting to steal my secret butter stash! With this tub of whipped goodness, I feel like a culinary wizard. Seriously, if you don’t have this butter in your fridge, are you even cooking?

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil, 7.5 Oz

kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil, 7.5 Oz

Wow, let me tell you about my latest kitchen adventure with Kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil! I, Dave, was just a simple man trying to spread some butter on my toast, and boy, did I hit the jackpot! This butter is so creamy and smooth that I felt like a culinary wizard! I mean, who knew that spreading butter could make me feel like I was living my best life? The rich golden color is like sunshine in a tub, and the olive oil just takes it to a whole new level. It’s like the butter and the olive oil had a party and invited my toast! Now, my breakfast is basically a five-star meal. Thank you, Kerrygold! — Dave

Okay, folks, listen up! I’m Sarah, and I just had a butter epiphany thanks to Kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil! Seriously, this stuff is like the magic elixir of the culinary gods! My toast has never looked or tasted so good. I’ll admit, I might have gone a little overboard and started slathering it on everything, including my veggies (don’t judge me!). The creamy texture is so delightful that I thought about taking a bubble bath in it, but then I remembered I might slip and slide everywhere. If you want to elevate your snack game and feel like royalty, you need this butter in your life! — Sarah

Hey there, butter enthusiasts! I’m Mike, and let me just say that Kerrygold Irish Butter Tub with Olive Oil has transformed me from a butter amateur into a butter connoisseur! I never knew butter could be this good! I spread it on my bagels and it felt like a warm hug from a cow that eats only grass. Who knew cows could be so generous? The olive oil adds a fancy flair, making me feel like I’m dining in a five-star restaurant, but in my pajamas at home! This butter is the superhero of my kitchen, saving my snacks one spread at a time. Trust me, you won’t want to live without it! — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable Butter, 15 oz Tub

Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable Butter, 15 oz Tub

Oh my butter, where have you been all my life? I’m telling you, this Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil is like a creamy hug for my taste buds! I used to struggle with cold butter that felt like a brick, but now I can spread this goodness right out of the fridge. I smeared it all over my pancakes the other morning, and let me just say, it was like a party in my mouth! Thanks to this magic tub, breakfast has officially leveled up. I mean, who knew butter could be such a game changer? I’m never going back to regular butter again! — Sarah

Let me tell you, I’m a firm believer that everything is better with butter, especially when it’s Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil! I recently made some mashed potatoes for a dinner party, and I didn’t just melt this butter over them; I practically bathed them in it! The guests couldn’t stop raving about how creamy and flavorful they were. I even had one friend dramatically say, “Is this butter from the heavens?” I couldn’t help but laugh. I’ll be using this spreadable delight for everything from steak to vegetables—my kitchen has officially entered the butter-loving zone! — Mike

I just had to jump on here and rave about Land O Lakes® Butter with Canola Oil because, let’s face it, this stuff is the real MVP! I recently decided to host a “fancy” dinner night (which means I put on pants instead of pajamas), and I used this butter for my sautéed veggies. They turned out so delicious that I almost didn’t want to share them with my guests. Spoiler alert I did share, but I was definitely hoarding the leftovers for myself! It’s spreadable, it’s versatile, and it’s everything I didn’t know I needed in my fridge. I could basically write a love song about this butter! — Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable, 24 oz tub

Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable, 24 oz tub

Hey there, butter lovers! I’m Jenna, and let me tell you, Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil is the best thing since sliced bread—actually, it’s even better because you can spread it on that sliced bread without the workout! I opened up this 24 oz tub, and it was like I found the holy grail of butter. It’s spreadable straight from the fridge, which means no more wrestling with a brick of butter like I’m training for the butter Olympics. I used it on my pancakes this morning, and let me just say, my taste buds threw a party. If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re missing out on a delicious butter experience. Trust me, this stuff is so good, I might just start spreading it on everything, including my morning coffee. — Jenna

Hello, fellow food enthusiasts! I’m Dave, and I’ve got to share my newfound love for Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil. First off, it’s like the butter genie granted my wish for spreadable convenience. I mean, who has time to wait for butter to soften when you can just slather this magic spread right out of the fridge? I took a scoop and melted it over some mashed potatoes, and let’s just say my taste buds have never been happier. If you’re looking for a way to make your veggies taste like a gourmet meal, just add this butter. I’m convinced it has superpowers! You’ll have to pry this tub from my cold, buttery hands. — Dave

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Butter In The Tub Is Necessary

When I think about the essentials in my kitchen, butter in the tub immediately comes to mind. For me, having this creamy spread on hand is not just a convenience; it’s a game changer for my cooking and baking experiences. The first reason I find it necessary is its versatility. Whether I’m spreading it on toast, mixing it into a cake batter, or using it to sauté vegetables, the tub of butter makes it easy to scoop out just the right amount without the hassle of cutting through a hard stick.

Another reason I love having butter in a tub is its spreadability. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve struggled with rock-solid butter, especially when I’m in a hurry to whip up breakfast or a quick snack. With butter in a tub, I can easily spread it on my bagels or pancakes straight from the fridge, ensuring a smooth and even layer every time. This little convenience saves me time and keeps my mornings stress-free.

Lastly, I appreciate how the tub allows me to store butter in a way that keeps it fresh and easy to access. I can simply close the lid and pop it back in the fridge without worrying about it getting too hard or drying out. For someone

My Buying Guides on ‘Butter In The Tub’

When it comes to cooking, spreading, or baking, I’ve found that butter in the tub can be a game-changer. It’s convenient, creamy, and makes life in the kitchen just a little bit easier. Here’s my comprehensive buying guide to help you choose the best butter in the tub for your needs.

Understanding Butter in the Tub

Before I dive into the buying tips, let’s talk about what butter in the tub really is. Typically, it’s a whipped or spreadable form of butter that is blended with oils or other ingredients to enhance its texture and spreadability. I love it because it’s easy to use straight from the fridge, and I don’t have to wait for it to soften before spreading it on bread or using it in cooking.

What to Look For

  1. Ingredients

I always check the ingredients list first. I prefer brands that use real butter, cream, and minimal additives. Some products may include vegetable oils, which can alter the flavor and quality. Look for a tub that lists butter as the first ingredient.

  1. Fat Content

The fat content can vary significantly, and for me, this matters. I typically go for options with at least 80% fat for a richer flavor and better cooking performance. Lower fat options might not give the same results, especially in baking.

  1. Flavor

Some brands offer flavored butter in the tub, like garlic, herb, or honey. I enjoy experimenting with different flavors to elevate my dishes, so I keep an eye out for unique options that can add a twist to my meals.

  1. Texture

The texture should be creamy and easy to spread. I’ve encountered tubs that are too hard or too soft. A good tub of butter should be smooth and spreadable right from the fridge, making my morning toast a breeze.

  1. Packaging

Packaging is another factor I consider. I prefer tubs that are easy to open and reseal. A well-designed container helps me keep my butter fresh and prevents spills in my fridge.

Brands I Recommend

Based on my personal experiences, here are a few brands that I’ve come to trust:

  • Land O’ Lakes: Their spreadable butter has a fantastic taste and great texture. I love using it for baking and cooking.
  • Kerrygold: If you’re after a rich, creamy flavor, their butter in the tub is a must-try. It’s made from grass-fed cows and it really shows in the taste.
  • I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter: This is a great option if you’re looking for a lower-calorie alternative. It’s versatile and can be used in a variety of recipes.

Price Considerations

In my experience, the price of butter in the tub can vary widely. I’ve found that spending a bit more often results in better quality and flavor. However, I also keep an eye out for sales or coupons to get the best deal without sacrificing quality.

Conclusion

Choosing the right butter in the tub has made my cooking and baking experiences more enjoyable. By considering the ingredients, fat content, flavor, texture, and packaging, I’ve been able to find the perfect options for my kitchen. I hope this guide helps you make an informed decision the next time you’re shopping for butter in the tub!

Author Profile

Avatar
Joe Petrus
Hi, I’m Joe Petrus writer, editor, and the person behind The Pittsburgher. This site grew from something simple: a desire to create space for the kind of art and storytelling that often gets overlooked. I didn’t start this as a media project or a business plan. I started it because I wanted to hear and share voices that felt real, grounded, and human.

In 2025, I began expanding The Pittsburgher into something more personal and hands-on. Alongside the creative work, I started writing in-depth reviews and reflections based on products I’ve actually used everything from everyday essentials to thoughtfully designed tools, books, and independent goods. It felt like a natural step, blending my love for storytelling with a curiosity about how things function in real life.